Prison Officers Call for Electric Stun Guns

Prison Officers Call for Electric Stun Guns – A Threat to Safety or a Necessary Protection?

The recent attack on officers at HMP Frankland by convicted terrorist Hashem Abedi has reignited demands for prison staff to be equipped with electric stun guns, commonly known as tasers. While the Prison Officers’ Association (POA) argues this is essential for officer safety, the proposal raises serious questions about the potential consequences for prison staff welfare, inmate safety, and the risk of misuse of force.

Calls for Stun Guns After a Violent Prison Attack

During a violent incident at HMP Frankland in County Durham, Hashem Abedi—jailed for his role in the Manchester Arena bombing—threw hot oil at staff and used makeshift weapons to stab officers. In response, the POA is now pushing for tasers to be issued to specially trained officers in high-risk facilities.

Mark Fairhurst, National Chair of the POA, told the BBC: “We want specially trained staff on site who respond to incidents with the ability to deploy taser to neutralise that threat.”

Existing Protective Equipment Deemed Inadequate

Currently, prison officers in the UK are armed only with extendable batons and PAVA spray (a type of synthetic pepper spray). The POA argues these tools are no longer sufficient in the face of increasingly dangerous and calculated attacks by high-risk inmates.

In light of these threats, the POA is also renewing its demand for stab vests to be made standard issue and for Supermax-style restrictions to be imposed on the most dangerous prisoners—an approach modelled on American high-security prison systems.

Impact on Prison Staff Welfare

While the need for greater protection is clear, critics warn that introducing electric stun guns could lead to increased stress, pressure, and potential moral injury among prison staff. Giving officers access to tasers without appropriate checks and balances may place them in ethically fraught positions, risking their mental health and professional wellbeing.

Former prison governor Ian Acheson told BBC Radio 4 that the current level of officer protection is “inadequate compared to the level of threat”, warning that action is needed to prevent the death of a prison officer on duty. However, equipping staff with tasers could also dramatically alter the dynamic between officers and inmates, possibly increasing tension rather than diffusing it.

Risks to Inmate Welfare and the Prison Environment

Beyond concerns for staff, there is significant anxiety about how stun guns might impact prisoner welfare. Introducing such devices into an already volatile environment could increase the risk of abuse of power or disproportionately affect vulnerable inmates, particularly those with mental health issues.

Campaigners and human rights organisations have previously voiced concern about similar proposals, noting that tasers have been linked to serious injuries and fatalities when misused or overused in custodial settings.

Government Response and Ongoing Reviews

Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood has confirmed an independent review of the incident involving Abedi, as well as an internal review into the effectiveness of current body armour and protection protocols. However, her statement made no reference to the introduction of stun guns, suggesting the issue remains contentious within government circles.

The Ministry of Justice has also temporarily suspended prisoner access to kitchen areas in separation units, acknowledging the security gap that allowed the attack to occur.

Balancing Security and Human Rights

It is clear that measures must be taken to enhance prison security and protect prison officers from serious harm. However, any solution must also consider the broader implications on staff mental health, prison culture, and the potential for abuse of authority. Equipping staff with tasers might solve one problem, only to create others—particularly if safeguards, training, and accountability measures are not firmly in place.

As the government considers its next steps, it must balance the urgent need to protect prison officers with its duty to uphold human rights and maintain safe, rehabilitative environments for all who live and work within the prison system.

How We Help

If you have any questions or concerns regarding this article or for legal representation of those currently serving prison sentences, call us on 0161 477 1121 or contact us online.