Justice Secretary Plans to Shut Women’s Prisons Amid Overcrowding Crisis

Plans to ease prison overcrowding focusses on women’s prisons.

Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood has announced a significant policy shift aimed at addressing the overcrowding crisis in the UK’s prison system, particularly focusing on reducing the number of women in prison.

The decision arises partly as a result of severe overcrowding in prisons, with more than 40% of adult prisons in England and Wales rated as having concerns, including high levels of violence, self-harm, and drug issues.

This crisis prompted emergency measures, including the early release of prisoners to alleviate pressure on the system.

What would the plans for women’s prisons involve?

This initiative includes:

• Establishment of a Women’s Justice Board: This new body aims to decrease the number of women being sent to prison, with an ambition towards eventually reducing the need for women’s prisons altogether. The board will likely explore alternatives to imprisonment for women, focusing on community-based sentences, rehabilitation, and addressing the root causes of female offending, which often differ from male offending patterns.

• Long-term Vision: Beyond immediate relief, Mahmood’s plan hints at a broader reform of how criminal justice addresses female offenders, aiming for a system where community sentences, mental health support, and rehabilitation play a more significant role than incarceration.

Reaction to the plans

The move has been met with mixed reactions.

There’s support from various quarters for recognizing that many women in prison have been victims of abuse or suffer from mental health issues or substance dependencies, suggesting imprisonment might not be the most effective solution for them.

However, there are also concerns about public safety and the capacity of the probation service to handle the increased number of early releases.

This policy shift does however reflect a broader debate on the effectiveness of imprisonment versus rehabilitation, particularly for demographics like women where systemic issues like domestic abuse, mental health, and substance abuse often precede criminal behavior.

The Prison Reform Trust said:

“The justice secretary’s commitment to establish a women’s justice board tasked with the aim of reducing the number of women in prison represents a historic moment for women’s justice reform…

After decades of advocacy on this issue by us and others, we are delighted by (the) announcement and look forward to working with the government to turn the promise of a fair and effective justice system for women into a reality.”

How We Can Help

If you have any questions or concerns regarding any of the developments raised in this article, you can contact us on 0161 477 1121 or email us for more information.